What a Great place for Stocking Stuffers…

Posted on November 1, 2025 by Indiana's Cool North

Looking for a unique place to grab those stocking stuffers and Christmas gifts, look no further than these small businesses.

Neighbors Mercantile

Neighbors Mercantile in Nappanee offers a warm, old-fashioned shopping experience filled with thoughtfully curated home décor, kitchen essentials, toys, apparel, and unique gifts. Shopping for stocking gifts is a delight. Their shelves host a treasure trove of small toys, pocket-sized games, novelty puzzles, mini plush friends, and colorful trinkets — perfect for creating playful and surprising holiday bundles that spark joy for both kids and grown-ups.

A Whole World of Good

📸: A Whole World of Goods

A Whole World of Good in LaPorte is the perfect place to find meaningful stocking stuffers. Discover fair-trade chocolates, handcrafted ornaments, small accessories, artisan soaps, journals, and thoughtful trinkets from around the world. Every tiny gift carries a story and supports global makers, making your holiday giving both heartfelt and impactful.

Albanese Candy

Albanese Candy (Hobart) has stocking stuffers that are delightfully chewy, colorful, and affordable. Think mini 12-flavor gummi bears or worms, sugar-free bears, festive Christmas gummies, and tiny treat packs. Whether you want fruity classics or seasonal gummies, every small bag brings a burst of flavor for holiday surprises.

Holiday Gift Gallery @ Art Barn School of Art

The Art Barn Holiday Gift Gallery in Valparaiso transforms the school into a festive wonderland, showcasing handcrafted treasures by regional artists — from jewelry, prints, and ornaments to glasswork, wood creations, and fiber art. Shoppers support local talent and Art Barn’s mission while finding unique, affordable gifts.

A Shipshewana Christmas

Shopping for stocking stuffers in Shipshewana is a delight, with charming markets and locally owned shops offering unique treasures. Discover handmade candies, wooden toys, cozy textiles, and Amish-crafted novelties that add warmth and whimsy to any stocking. It’s the perfect place to find thoughtful, small gifts with heart and hometown character.